Doing a critical review dissertation

This applies especially to people doing PhDs on a part-time basis, where their research might extend over six or more years. Aligning herself with the author, Author Year states that Increasingly, examiners at post-graduate level are looking for the detail of how you chose which evidence you decided to refer to.

There may also be key sources of publications for your subject that are accessible electronically, such as collections of policy documents, standards, archive material, videos, and audio-recordings.

Taylor and Procter of The University of Toronto have some useful suggested questions to ask yourself at the beginning of your reading: It is an important showcase of your talents of: This may not always be the case.

What is already known or understood about this topic? Less convincing is the broad-sweeping generalisation that This person can help you identify relevant sources, and create effective electronic searches: The approach taken by the author provides the opportunity to examine The reader is rewarded with Often, the literature review will end with a statement of the research question s.

Why do I need a literature review? Examples of ways you might structure your literature review are: Critical review in dissertation Sometimes the students get confused between critical review and literature review. Help is available regarding how to avoid plagiarism and it is worth checking it out.

Wherever possible, use original source material rather than summaries or reviews by others. This is a simple paraphrase with no critical comment. In each example, the section that refers to a source has been highlighted in bold. What time period am I interested in? Your interpretation may be self-evident to you, but it may not be to everyone else.

It must be clear to the reader where it is going: Keeping a record Keeping a record of your search strategy is useful, to prevent you duplicating effort by doing the same search twice, or missing out a significant and relevant sector of literature because you think you have already done that search.

You will also need to be ready to answer them in a viva if you will be having one. Therefore, the suggestion made by Author Year …is difficult to support.

Writing a Critical Review

Use of source material in example b: So, despite having access to electronic databases and to electronic searching techniques, it can be surprisingly useful to have a pile of journals actually on your desk, and to look through the contents pages, and the individual articles.

For example, you could use a table to display the key differences between two or more: Engage in a dialogue with the literature, you are not just providing a summary. According to Author Year teaching towards examinations is not as effective as it is in other areas of the curriculum.

What types of publications am I using e. The process of conducting and reporting your literature review can help you clarify your own thoughts about your study. This detailed and rigorously argued The note below the example then explains how the writer has used the source material.

I find it slightly ironic that such an anglo-centric view is What research question s are you asking? It is essential to check that you have constructed your synthesis well, and with sufficient supporting evidence. If you are required to record and present your search strategy, you may be able to include the technical details of the search strategy as an appendix to your thesis.

They may already have copies of articles that you can work with. The difference between descriptive and critical review can be best explained through the following table: It must relate to your study.A critical review is not to be mistaken for the literature review.

A 'critical review' is a complete type of text, discussing one particular article or book in detail.

The 'literature review', which also needs to be 'critical', is a part of a larger type of text e.g. a chapter of your dissertation. While literature review is a collection of facts and figures on dissertation topic, the critical review is about questioning the reliability and feasibility of these facts and figures for.

Doing a literature review Study guide For a printer Writing a dissertation, What is critical reading? What is critical writing?

Doing a literature review

The focus of the Study Guide is the literature review within a dissertation or a thesis, but many of the ideas are transferable to other kinds of writing, such as an extended essay, or a report. A literature review surveys books, scholarly articles, and any other sources relevant to a particular issue, area of research, or theory, and by so doing, provides a description, summary, and critical evaluation of these works in relation to the research problem being investigated.

Literature. Doing a Literature Review: Releasing the Research Imagination (SAGE Study Skills Series) [Chris Hart] on *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers. The ultimate guide to the what, how, and why of literature reviewing, the Second Edition of the classic text shows how the literature review will unlock the full potential of one′s research /5(4).

This is a multidisciplinary guide for graduate students interested in first steps to consider when starting a literature review for their dissertation.

How to write critical review in a dissertation? Download
Doing a critical review dissertation
Rated 3/5 based on 58 review